Tech-invite3GPPspaceIETFspace
21222324252627282931323334353637384‑5x

Content for  TR 21.900  Word version:  18.2.0

Top   Top   Up   Prev   Next
0…   4…   4.4…   4.6…   4.7…   4.10…   5…   6…   7…

 

4.7  "Freezing" of specificationsp. 20

A TSG may decide that a specification is sufficiently stable that it may be considered "frozen". That is, only CRs for essential corrections of errors shall be considered except as discussed below (see clause 4.6.2 and in particular the derogation statement below Table 4A).
At the same time, a new major version may be developed for inclusion of new features.
Normally, all specifications of a Release will be frozen when the TSGs decide that the functionality of the Release is stable - i.e that all new features to be included in the Release have been defined and that all new or modified functionality required to implement those features has been incorporated into the specifications. At this point, the Release as a whole shall be declared to be "frozen", and its constituent specifications shall likewise be "frozen".
A CR of category B or C (and any associated category A mirrors) to a frozen version of a specification (in a given Release) shall only be an alignment of the specification with the agreed functionality of the Release as provided for in other specifications of that Release, or for internal consistency of an individual specification. Such a CR may add to, remove from, or modify the functionality of a frozen specification to ensure a consistent specification set across a particular Release.
Correction CRs (category F and any associated category A mirrors) to a frozen version of a specification (in a given Release) shall fit into one of the following classifications:
  • A CR to introduce an essential correction, i.e. where a frequently occurring case is not handled properly because there is some error or significant ambiguity in the specification.
  • A CR to remedy the incorrect implementation of a previously approved CR (of any category).
Up

4.8  "Closing" of specificationsp. 21

A TSG may decide that a specification of a certain Release will no longer be maintained that it may be considered "closed". That is, no further Change Requests to the specification of this Release shall be considered. The specification of the Release remains available (e.g., for referencing reasons), but no further Change Requests shall be produced, even corrective ones to align with the equivalent specification of a subsequent Release.
All specifications of a Release will be closed when the TSGs decide that the Release is no longer to be maintained (i.e., the Release is closed). A specification of a Release can only be closed if the specification(s) for previous Releases are closed. At the same time, higher major versions of the specification may be under development (i.e. for a later Release).
Up

4.9  "Withdrawing" of specificationsp. 21

A TSG may decide to withdraw a specification which is obsolete if its remaining available would confuse implementors (for example, if it contained provisions which were contradictory to provisions of other, later, specifications).
Before withdrawing a specification, the TSG shall ensure that no references are made to it from any other 3GPP specification (and raise appropriate Change Requests to eliminate any such references discovered).
A TSG shall use the procedure in clause 4.9B to withdraw specifications and functionality.
Up

4.9A  "Withdrawing" of functionalityp. 21

A TSG may decide to withdraw functionality.
Before withdrawing functionality, the TSG shall:
  • raise Change Requests to eliminate any references made to this functionality from any 3GPP specifications; and
  • move text within specifications which were created for the functionality, that is applicable to other functionality as well, to other appropriate specifications.

4.9B  Procedure for withdrawing of specifications and functionalityp. 21

4.9B.1Void

4.9B.2  Diligent assessmentp. 21

The decision whether to withdraw (a) specification(s) or whether to remove functionality from within specifications shall only be taken once thorough consideration has been given to the implications and applicability of the action.
The withdrawing of a specification or functionality shall be explicitly identified as one of the objectives of a work item.
The withdrawing of a specification or functionality may be documented in:
  1. a work item that defines new functionality that will obsolete the specification or functionality; or
  2. documented in a work item that is solely for the purpose of withdrawing.
Technical Enhancements and Improvement (TEI) and other similar general purpose enhancement work items shall not be used for the withdrawing of a specification or functionality.
The assessment of whether to withdraw functionality may extend beyond 3GPP TSGs and their working groups. A notice shall be placed on the 3GPP site to solicit comments from other concerned parties and shall clearly indicate which specifications and functionality are considered for withdrawal, including which versions of the specification would be affected, the date at which a decision will be taken and the responsible TSG to which third parties may send related Liaison Statements or other correspondence.
A study item may contain, as one of its objectives and/or its conclusions, consideration of whether existing functionality should be withdrawn and the identification of the impact of the withdrawing of functionality or specifications.
Up

4.9B.3  Changes to affected specificationsp. 22

Removal of functionality shall be done using the normal change request procedure (see subclause 4.6).

4.9B.4  Considerations for ongoing maintenance, enhancement and new Release versions of specificationsp. 22

When a specific version or all versions in a specific Release of a specification, are withdrawn further versions of the specification in the same Release shall not be created and the specification shall not be promoted to a subsequent Release.
Evolution of specifications and functionality in Releases unaffected by the withdrawal are allowed.
A Category B or Category C CR that adds to or modifies a specification or functionality that has been withdrawn in a subsequent version shall clearly state on the CR cover sheet in the Summary of change that the subsequent version of the specification or functionality has been withdrawn.
Category A CRs for Releases in which the specification or functionality has been withdrawn shall not be produced.
Up

Up   Top   ToC